Monday, July 14, 2014

15 classic cases where justice held & maintenance denied to undeserving women !!


Bombay HC : NO MAINTENANCE u/s 125 Cr. P C to deserting wife

Allahabad HC : Major daughters (i.e.) above 18 not entitled to maintenance u.s 125 Crpc.


Supreme Court of India : S125 CrPC maintenance adjustable against maint in matri. proceedings & not over & above Sec 24 HMA maint.


Bombay HC : IF Wife can't prove DV, children ALSO NOT entitled maintenance under DV


Madras HC  : Employed, earning wife NOT entitled INTerim MAINT us 24 HMA : Sathasivam J [latr CJI of India !]


Bombay HC : No maint us 125CrPC deserting wife. But much higher (6x) maint & lumpsum 4 child living with wife


Karnataka HC, 2005 : No Int Maint us 24 HMA for working wife (doctor). Husband to maintain kid !


SUPREME COURT OF INDIA : Wife employed and earning a salary is NOT entitled to interim maint u/s 24 HMA, even though husband is earning four times MORE than the wife. Child – Daughter gets interim maintenance.


P&H HC : NO interim maint for wife earning 50000 pm &NO proof of husband earnings ; husb out of job


Supreme court : Maintenance to be borne by husband AND wife in proportion to their salaries !!


Bombay HC 1991: IF MAINT case undr S-24 & S-125 IDENTICAL, only sec24 continues, sec125 stayed


DELHI HC : Ablaa WIFE already making moolah in civil case of sec 125 CrPC cannot make MORE moolah using DV !!


Madhya Pradesh HC : No Pendente Lite (Sec 24) to educated wife .


Uttaranchal HC : Employed & deserting wife : NO maintenance u/s 125. Even though wife's salary is only Rs 2200/- p.m.

Delhi HC : No Interim maintenance to wife earning Rs 56thousands per month :



Errata :

Kolkata High Court  : NO ONE believes hubby/wife on earnings!! wife says hubby earns 18000, hubby say 1800!, court orders 1500 pm!!





FOLLOW on twitter or on wordpress or  FOR 100s of high court and supreme court cases
Father of a lovely daughter, criminal in the eyes of a wife, son of an compassionate elderly mother, old timer who hasn't given up, Male, activist